patching...
Breaking: Three Injured in Lorton Fire on Furnace Road »
Welcome back, Patch Blogger!

Cell Phone Towers a Growing Presence in Fairfax County Schools

Installations bring in revenue, but also health concerns

 

Did you happen to notice the massive cell phone tower wedged between the stadium lights on the campus of South County Secondary School? If you didn't, that's the idea. The companies that own them would prefer that they blend in. If you think it's unusual for a cell phone to be on public property or on school property, it isn't. That doesn't mean it isn't controversial. For now, the tower at South County SS is the only one in Lorton-area schools. Erica Hendry, editor of the Vienna Patch has a detailed report.

A Growing Trend

With the approval earlier this week of a cell tower along the southern bleachers of its football field, Madison High School in Vienna joined the growing number of properties across Northern Virginia that leases land for the construction of cell towers. Last night the Fairfax County Planning Commission approved a proposal for a tower at Thoreau Middle School, also in Vienna.

A Modern Necessity?

The more than 100 cell towers and 700 antennas installed throughout Fairfax County are a response to the increased use of devices like smart phones and iPads across Northern Virginia, and the call for better and faster service that's followed has cell phone carriers scrambling to keep up.

Text messaging, e-mailing and photo and video sharing have driven the demand for larger networks that can process more data, said Len Forkas, whose Reston-based company Milestone Communications already owns or manages more than 200 towers across the greater Washington, D.C., region and would do the same for the two towers in Vienna.

One of the more striking illustrations of the problem, Forkas says, is that iPhone users make up about 15 percent of AT&T's customers, but take up 90 percent of that network's capacity.

"This is the trend that's happening all over region, all over the country," Forkas said. "The network is going to have to be a lot faster, more robust and process a lot more data. And in order to do that cell carriers have to build more sites closer to where people live."

Where people live is often near schools or educational campuses, which have looked to cell towers as a source of revenue for years. Fairfax County Public Schools began leasing land for cell tower construction in 1995, and today, 17 schools have Milestone owned or operated structures on their property, including nearby Oakton and McLean high Schools. Some, like Centerville and South Lakes High Schools, have two or more poles on their properties.

As many as four cell phone carriers, like AT&T or Verizon, can lease space on a tower at once.  Lease on the towers last 30 years, Forkas said, though the poles themselves are built to last a century.

Schools are ideal locations for these towers, Forkas says, because they often have existing structures, such as field light poles, in place; are easy for maintenance vehicles to access; and don't interfere with the character of residential neighborhoods, Forkas said. The alternative is putting them in more prominent places, he said, and pouring that money into a privately owned property, instead of into the schools.

Particularly as the economy has worsened and school boards have searched for ways to close deficits in their budgets, revenue from cell towers has provided some relief, or funded programs that may have otherwise been eliminated.

In the past five years, revenue from the towers on FCPS property have totaled about $3.7 million, said Lee Ann Pender, director of facilities and transportation services for the school system.

That number seems small in the face of the roughly $2 billion FCPS spends on its schools each year, but Pender says it helps pay for projects and programs in safety and security and administrative technology, including the systems required for the FCPS Emergency Communication System.

Milestone collects rent from the wireless carriers on its towers, 40 percent of which goes to FCPS. Schools receive $25,000 each time a tower is built, and then $5,000 from each wireless carrier that leases space on the tower.

Municipalities do hold cell towers to standards set by the Federal Communications Commission, which regulates how much frequency the poles can emit, commissioner Frank de la Fe said at the hearing for the Madison tower. The existing poles in Fairfax County, along with the proposed poles, are a thousand times lower than that standard, Forkas said.

"That's the only standard we have, and we are significantly below threshold for safety," Forkas said.

Parents Concerned Over Health Risks

Several residents and vocal parent groups, like Falls Church's Protect Schools and nationwide Parents Against Cell Towers (PACT), have argued there are other ways to find revenue besides putting cell towers on school campuses, where they believe radiation is emitted too close to their children.

Federal law prevents municipalities from blocking cell phone towers based on health concerns, even with the support of American or European studies that oppose the FCC position on the link between cell towers and cancer, planning commission member Frank de la Fe said at the hearing for the Madison tower.

Municipalities do hold cell towers to standards set by the Federal Communications Commission, which regulates how much frequency the poles can emit, de la Fe said. On its web site, the FCC says evidence linking radiation frequency and cancer are inconclusive. The existing poles in Fairfax County, along with the proposed poles, are a thousand times lower than that standard, Forkas said.

"That's the only standard we have, and we are significantly below threshold for safety," Forkas said.

 A 2005 FCPS-led study supports that statement, though some opponents to the towers complain that the study doesn't list specific frequency amounts, and instead, only lists the number of times a pole's frequency is below the FCC standard.

But federal law can't stop cities and towns from banning towers in certain areas, or adopting measures to restrict them, and several governing boards across the country have done so. The Los Angeles Unified School District banned towers from school property almost a decade ago. The Town of Vienna, whose boundaries fall just short of the planned location for the Madison and Thoreau towers, limits cell towers to a handful of town-owned properties, the Virginia Power substation on Center Street North, existing utility towers along the Washington and Old Dominion Trail, and a small section of Maple Ave East, West Mill Street Northeast, and Dominion Road Northeast.

Last month, a town board in Hempstead, N.Y., banned wireless companies from constructing equipment within 1,500 feet of schools, homes, day care centers and places of worship.

The closest residence to the Madison tower is 231 feet. The closest building to the proposed tower at Thoreau, a church building on Amanda Place, is 36 feet, according to Milestone's application.

"When I hold a cell phone right against my head, that's significantly more dangerous than being exposed to these towers," Forkas said.  "It's part of our life, part of our culture."

What's your opinion about cell phone towers on school property? Tell us in the comments.

Leave a comment